Skip to content
FriendsPantry

Vietnamese · Soups

Phở bò tái chín (Hanoi beef pho with rare and well-done beef)

Non-vegetarian

Phở bò tái chín · phở bò tái chín

A clear, deeply beefy bone broth perfumed with charred onion, ginger, star anise, cinnamon and cloves, poured over flat rice noodles, slices of simmered brisket (chín) and paper-thin raw beef (tái) that cooks in the bowl. The northern style is restrained: lots of spring onion, a little herb, and lime and chilli on the side.

Phở bò tái chín (Hanoi beef pho with rare and well-done beef) is a Vietnamese soup, ready in about 5 hours 40 minutes and made with oxtail, beef brisket and rice noodles. It serves 6 and is rated intermediate to cook.

Start cooking
Phở bò tái chín (Hanoi beef pho with rare and well-done beef)
Photo: Shutterstock, via TasteAtlas · licensed
Prep
40 min
Cook
5 h
Total
5 h 40 min
Serves
6
Level
Intermediate
Calories
1295

Main ingredients

Ingredients

6 servings

For the broth

For the bowls

To serve

Method

Broth

15 min
  1. Step 1

    Put the oxtail (opens in a new tab) and shank in a stockpot, cover with cold water and bring to a hard boil for 5 minutes. Drain, rinse the bones and the pot well to remove the scum; this is what keeps the broth clear.

    Food safety: Wash hands, boards and knives after handling raw meat, and keep it apart from salad and other ready-to-eat food.

Spice bag

5 h 12 min
  1. Step 2

    Meanwhile char the halved onions (opens in a new tab) and ginger, cut side down, in a dry frying pan (or directly over a gas flame) until blackened in patches, about 10 minutes. Rinse off any loose ash. Toast the star anise (opens in a new tab), cinnamon, cloves (opens in a new tab), cardamom and coriander seeds in the same pan for 1–2 minutes until fragrant, then tie them in a muslin bag.

  2. Step 3

    Return the bones to the pot with the 5 litres of water and the charred onion (opens in a new tab) and ginger. Bring just to the boil, skim, then lower to a bare simmer. Add the brisket (opens in a new tab) and simmer gently, uncovered, skimming often.

  3. Step 4

    After about 1½ hours, when a skewer slides easily into the brisket (opens in a new tab), lift it out and plunge it into cold water for 10 minutes so it stays moist and pale, then wrap and refrigerate. Add the spice bag to the broth.

    • 90 min
    • low heat
  4. Step 5

    Keep simmering the broth very gently for another 3 hours, topping up with a little hot water if the bones poke out. Remove the spice bag after 45 minutes so the anise (opens in a new tab) does not dominate.

    • 180 min
    • low heat

    The surface should only tremble; a rolling boil makes the broth cloudy.

  5. Step 6

    Strain the broth through a fine sieve. Season with the fish sauce (opens in a new tab), sugar (opens in a new tab) and salt: it should taste slightly too salty on its own, as the noodles absorb seasoning. Skim off excess fat, leaving a few golden droplets. Keep at a rolling simmer for serving.

    Liquid being strained through a sieve
    How it looks · Photo: Katerina Holmes on Pexels

Bowls

15 min
  1. Step 7

    Soak dried noodles in warm water for 20 minutes, then blanch portions for 15–30 seconds in boiling water (fresh noodles just need a quick dip) and drain into warmed bowls. Slice the cooled brisket (opens in a new tab) thinly across the grain.

    • 10 min
  2. Step 8

    Top each bowl with a few slices of brisket (opens in a new tab), the halved spring onion (opens in a new tab) whites, and the raw beef slices spread in a single layer. Ladle (opens in a new tab) over the boiling broth so it cooks the beef to pink, then scatter with sliced spring onion (opens in a new tab) greens, soaked onion and coriander.

    • 5 min

    Food safety: Rare beef cooked only by hot broth is not fully cooked; use very fresh whole-muscle beef from a trusted butcher, and avoid it for pregnant people, young children and anyone with a weakened immune system.

To serve

1 min
  1. Step 9

    Serve at once with lime (opens in a new tab) wedges, sliced chilli and, if you like, bean sprouts (opens in a new tab) and basil (opens in a new tab) for each person to add.

    • 1 min
    A finished dish being plated
    How it looks · Photo: Willians Huerta on Pexels

At a glance

Phở bò tái chín (Hanoi beef pho with rare and well-done beef) in 4 stages: broth in a pot, then spice bag in a pan, then bowls in a pot, then to serve in a bowl.
  1. 1 · Broth in a pot

    • Oxtail
    • Beef shank (bone-in, cross-cut)
    • Beef brisket
    • Onion
    • Fresh ginger
    • Fish sauce
    • Sugar
    • Salt
  2. then char

    2 · Spice bag in a pan

    • Star anise / anise
    • Cinnamon stick
    • Cloves
    • Black cardamom
    • Ground coriander
  3. then soak

    3 · Bowls in a pot

    • Rice noodles
    • Beef sirloin steak
    • Spring onion
    • Onion
    • Coriander leaves
  4. then serve

    4 · To serve in a bowl

    • Lime
    • Fresh red chilli
    • Bean sprouts
    • Basil

About this dish

Origin
Northern Vietnam (Hà Nội and Nam Định), Vietnam · Well documentedPho took shape in the Red River delta in the early 20th century; 'tái chín' is the bowl ordered with both rare and well-done beef. Hanoi bowls skip the hoisin and big herb plates common in the south.Also popular in United States, Australia, FranceMore food from Vietnam
Map of the region around Vietnam, with Vietnam highlighted
Vietnam
Dish
Breakfast · Lunch · Dinner · Soups · Noodles · Main courses · Breakfast dishes · Noodle soups
Cooking method
Simmered, Toasted, Boiled
Taste
aromatic / warmly spiced, savoury, umami, fresh
Diet
No gluten ingredients · Dairy-free · No nut ingredients · High-protein
All labelsNon-vegetarian · No gluten ingredients · Dairy-free · Egg-free · No nut ingredients · Alcohol-free · Pork-free · High-protein
Worked out from the ingredients. How labels work
Good for
Make-ahead · Batch cooking

Allergens

  • Contains: Fishfrom fish sauce
  • May contain: Crustaceansfrom fish sauce

Based on typical versions of these ingredients and not verified allergen-free. Brands differ and cross-contact happens, so always check labels. For severe allergies, follow your clinician’s advice.

Nutrition

1295 kcal per serving

Estimated

1 serving ≈ 1453 g · recipe makes 6

Where the energy comes from

  • Protein 28%
  • Carbohydrate 21%
  • Fat 51%
Nutrition per serving and per 100 g
NutrientPer servingPer 100 g*
Energy1295 kcal89 kcal
Protein88.2 g6.1 g
Carbohydrate68.2 g4.7 g
Net carbohydrate64.5 g4.4 g
Sugars——
Added sugars2.1 g0.1 g
Fibre3.8 g0.3 g
Fat72.1 g5 g
Saturated fat30.4 g2.1 g
Trans fat——
Cholesterol262 mg18 mg
Sodium2112 mg145 mg
Salt equivalent5.3 g0.4 g
Vitamins & minerals per serving
Potassium
1662 mg
Calcium
210 mg
Iron
9.7 mg
Magnesium
135 mg
Vitamin A (RAE)
20 µg
Vitamin C
19 mg
Vitamin D
—
Vitamin B12
11.2 µg
Folate (DFE)
60 µg

How these numbers were made

  • Calculated from USDA FoodData Central (SR Legacy) per-100 g values and the listed quantities.
  • *Per 100 g of combined raw ingredients; the cooked dish may weigh more or less.
  • Optional ingredients are not included: bean sprouts, basil.
  • Oxtail: Raw beef short ribs (lean and fat) used as a stand-in; USDA SR Legacy has no oxtail entry. Both are fatty, collagen-rich bone-in cuts — recipes count only the edible portion.
  • Beef brisket: Beef chuck (raw) used as a stand-in; whole packer brisket has a similar mix of lean and fat, with more fat in the point and less in the flat.
  • Star anise / anise: Anise seed (FDC 171316) used as a stand-in for star anise.
  • Black cardamom: Green cardamom (FDC 170919) used as a stand-in; black cardamom is smoky and used whole in small amounts.
  • “—” means the value isn’t known for enough of the ingredients; it is never zero by default.
  • Values are estimates for guidance, not for medical dosing. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service. FoodData Central, 2019. fdc.nal.usda.gov.

Good to know

Tips

  • Freeze the steak for 30–40 minutes before slicing so you can cut it almost translucent.
  • Make the broth a day ahead: once chilled, the fat sets on top and is easy to lift off.

Common mistakes

  • Skipping the initial blanch of the bones, which leaves the broth grey and murky.
  • Pouring merely hot broth over the raw beef; it must be at a rolling boil to cook the slices.

Serve with

  • In Hanoi, pho is breakfast, often with quẩy (fried dough sticks) torn into the broth.
  • Offer garlic vinegar and chilli sauce at the table instead of hoisin for a northern feel.

Food safety

  • Rare beef cooked only by hot broth is not fully cooked; use very fresh whole-muscle beef from a trusted butcher, and avoid it for pregnant people, young children and anyone with a weakened immune system.
  • Wash hands, boards and knives after handling raw meat, and keep it apart from salad and other ready-to-eat food.

Storage

  • Broth keeps 4 days refrigerated or 3 months frozen. Store noodles, brisket and broth separately.

Reheating

  • Bring the broth back to a rolling boil before assembling new bowls.

Variations

  • Phở tái: Only rare beef in the bowl, no brisket.
  • Phở chín: Only well-done meat (brisket or flank), good for those who avoid rare beef.
  • Phở tái nạm gầu: Southern-style bowls with rare beef, flank and fatty brisket, served with a big plate of herbs, sprouts and hoisin.
What does 'tái chín' mean?

Tái means rare and chín means cooked through: the bowl comes with raw beef that cooks in the broth plus slices of simmered brisket.

Original editorial recipe · FriendsPantry editorial · source: TasteAtlas (dish facts) · Not yet independently reviewed · Added

Recipe DNA

How this dish is built

Built from the recipe’s own sections. Each band’s width is its share of the dish by weight. Choose a component to see what it does.

The spice and seasoning backbone

For the spice bag

Used in step 2

Reviews & corrections

Reviews come from signed-in cooks and appear after a moderator checks them. We never show made-up ratings.