Skip to content
FriendsPantry

American · Breads & flatbreads

New York-style bagels

Vegetarian

Dense, chewy bagels with a shiny, blistered crust, made from a stiff dough that is cold-retarded overnight, briefly boiled and then baked hot.

New York-style bagels is an American bread from United States, ready in about 14 hours 45 minutes and made with bread flour, instant yeast and honey. It serves 8 and is rated intermediate to cook.

Start cooking

No licensed photograph of this dish yet.

Prep
40 min
Cook
35 min
Rest
1 h 30 min
Total
14 h 45 min
Serves
8
Level
Intermediate
Calories
233

Includes a 12-hour overnight cold retard in the fridge (12–18 hours is fine).

Main ingredients

Ingredients

8 bagels

For boiling

Toppings

Method

Boiling

1 h 17 min
  1. Step 1

    Mix the flour, yeast, salt, honey (opens in a new tab) and 280 g water into a stiff, shaggy dough. Knead 10–12 minutes (low speed in a mixer) until smooth and very firm. Rest covered 30 minutes.

    Hands kneading dough on a floured surface
    How it looks · Photo: Klaus Nielsen on Pexels
  2. Step 2

    Divide into 8 pieces of about 100 g and shape: roll each into a 25 cm rope, wrap it around your hand so the ends overlap under your palm, and roll the join on the counter to seal. Set on a lightly oiled, lined tray.

    • 15 min
  3. Step 3

    Cover tightly and refrigerate 12–18 hours. This slow cold retard builds the flavour and the blistered crust.

    • 2 min
  4. Step 4

    Next day, take the bagels out 30–60 minutes before baking. Check readiness with the float test: drop one into cold water — if it floats within 10 seconds it is ready. Heat the oven (opens in a new tab) to 230 °C and bring the 3 l water and baking soda (opens in a new tab) to a boil.

Toppings

30 min
  1. Step 5

    Boil 3–4 at a time for 45–60 seconds per side. Lift out with a slotted spoon (opens in a new tab), drain briefly and dip the tops into seeds if using.

    Food safety: Lower bagels gently into the boiling water away from you to avoid splashes.

  2. Step 6

    Bake on the lined tray 18–20 minutes, turning the tray halfway, until deep golden-brown. Cool at least 20 minutes on a rack.

At a glance

New York-style bagels in 2 stages: boiling in a pot, then toppings in a pot.
  1. 1 · Boiling in a pot

    • Baking soda
  2. then boil

    2 · Toppings in a pot

    • Sesame seeds
    • Poppy seeds

About this dish

Origin
New York, United States · Commonly attributedBagels came to New York with Jewish immigrants from Eastern Europe (they are documented in Kraków, Poland); the large, malty, chewy New York style developed there.Also popular in Canada, Poland, IsraelMore food from United States
Map of the region around United States, with United States highlighted
United States
Dish
Breakfast · Brunch · Breads & flatbreads
Cooking method
Boiled, Oven-baked, Fermented
Taste
savoury, mild, sweet
Diet
Vegetarian (lacto-ovo) · Dairy-free · No nut ingredients
All labelsVegetarian (lacto-ovo) · Eggetarian · Lacto-vegetarian · Ovo-vegetarian · Pescatarian · Flexitarian-friendly · Dairy-free · Egg-free · No nut ingredients · Alcohol-free · Pork-free · Beef-free · Low-fat · DASH-style
With the listed swaps: Vegan, Plant-basedWorked out from the ingredients. How labels work
Good for
Make-ahead · Freezer-friendly
Techniques
Baking · Boiling · Kneading · Fermentation

Allergens

  • Contains: Wheatfrom bread flour
  • Contains: Glutenfrom bread flour
  • Contains, can be adapted: Sesamefrom sesame seeds

Based on typical versions of these ingredients and not verified allergen-free. Brands differ and cross-contact happens, so always check labels. For severe allergies, follow your clinician’s advice.

Nutrition

233 kcal per serving

Calculated

1 serving ≈ 95 g · recipe makes 8

Where the energy comes from

  • Protein 13%
  • Carbohydrate 82%
  • Fat 4%
Nutrition per serving and per 100 g
NutrientPer servingPer 100 g
Energy233 kcal245 kcal
Protein7.7 g8.1 g
Carbohydrate47.1 g49.6 g
Net carbohydrate45.4 g47.8 g
Sugars1.7 g1.8 g
Added sugars1.5 g1.6 g
Fibre1.6 g1.7 g
Fat1.1 g1.1 g
Saturated fat0.2 g0.2 g
Trans fat——
Cholesterol0 mg0 mg
Sodium521 mg548 mg
Salt equivalent1.3 g1.4 g
Vitamins & minerals per serving
Potassium
68 mg
Calcium
13 mg
Iron
2.8 mg
Magnesium
17 mg
Vitamin A (RAE)
0 µg
Vitamin C
0 mg
Vitamin D
0 µg
Vitamin B12
0 µg
Folate (DFE)
192 µg

How these numbers were made

  • Calculated from USDA FoodData Central (SR Legacy) per-100 g values and the listed quantities.
  • Optional ingredients are not included: sesame seeds, poppy seeds.
  • “—” means the value isn’t known for enough of the ingredients; it is never zero by default.
  • Values are estimates for guidance, not for medical dosing. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service. FoodData Central, 2019. fdc.nal.usda.gov.

Good to know

Tips

  • A longer boil (up to 90 seconds a side) gives a thicker, chewier crust.

Common mistakes

  • A soft, high-hydration dough gives puffy bread rolls rather than bagels.
  • Over-proofed bagels wrinkle and deflate in the water.

Serve with

  • Split and toast with cream cheese, smoked salmon, red onion and capers.

Storage

  • Best the same day; freeze split bagels up to 2 months.

Reheating

  • Toast from frozen.

Variations

  • Everything bagels: Top with a mix of sesame, poppy seeds, dried garlic, dried onion and flaky salt.
  • Cinnamon-raisin: Knead in 100 g raisins and 1 tbsp cinnamon.

Original editorial recipe · FriendsPantry editorial · Not yet independently reviewed · Added

Recipe DNA

How this dish is built

Built from the recipe’s own sections. Each band’s width is its share of the dish by weight. Choose a component to see what it does.

What the dish is built around

Main ingredient

Used in step 1

Timeline and readiness cues

  1. Mix and knead · about 40 min

    Weigh everything. Knead until smooth and elastic: a small piece stretches thin enough to see light through (the windowpane test).

  2. First rise (bulk) · about 12 h

    About doubled, domed, jiggly, with bubbles on the sides. A floured finger poked in leaves a dent that fills slowly.

  3. Rest · about 30 min

    Covered so it doesn't dry out; relaxed dough rolls and shapes without springing back.

  4. Final proof · about 45 min

    Poke test: the dent springs back slowly and only partly. Springs back fast = needs longer; doesn't spring back = over-proofed, bake now.

  5. Bake · about 30 min at 230 °C

    Deep golden; bread sounds hollow when tapped underneath, or reads 93–96 °C inside (enriched breads 88–90 °C).

  6. Cool · about 20 min

    Cool on a rack before slicing — the crumb is still setting; cutting hot bread makes it gummy.

  7. Start to finish: about 14 h 45 min. Times are a guide — warmth changes everything; follow the cues.

The dough

The dough in baker's percentages. Flour = 100%.
IngredientRoleWeightBaker’s %
Bread flourFlour500 g100%
WaterWater280 g56%
HoneySugar15 g3%
SaltSalt10 g2%
Instant yeastYeast4 g0.8%
Total flour
500 g
Hydration
56%
With milk, eggs…
56.5%
Wholegrain
0%

Hydration = water ÷ flour × 100. Milk is about 87% water and eggs about 75%, so they’re shown separately as “with milk, eggs…”.

  • Medium dough (55–65%) — soft and easy to knead; sandwich loaves and rolls.
  • Salt 2% — normal for bread.

If something goes wrong

  • Spreads flat / no oven spring

    Likely causes

    • Over-proofed
    • Weak shaping (no surface tension)
    • Oven not hot enough
    • Too much water for the flour

    What to do

    • Shorten the proof; bake when the poke springs back slowly
    • Shape tightly so the skin is taut
    • Preheat fully (30+ minutes; with a stone or Dutch oven, 45)
    • Lower hydration or use bread flour
  • Pale crust

    Likely causes

    • Oven too cool
    • Too little sugar or no milk/egg for browning
    • Over-fermented (yeast ate the sugars)

    What to do

    • Check the oven with a thermometer
    • Brush with egg wash or milk
    • Shorten the fermentation
  • Burnt bottom

    Likely causes

    • Tray too close to the heat
    • Dark tray absorbs more heat
    • Too much sugar in the dough

    What to do

    • Bake on the middle shelf
    • Double up trays or use a light-coloured one
    • Lower the temperature 10–15 °C and bake a little longer
  • Crust too hard or thick

    Likely causes

    • Baked too long at too low a temperature
    • No steam at the start

    What to do

    • Bake hotter for a shorter time
    • Add steam for the first 15 minutes (tray of boiling water, or a covered Dutch oven)
    • Cool under a tea towel for a softer crust

Reviews & corrections

Reviews come from signed-in cooks and appear after a moderator checks them. We never show made-up ratings.