Skip to content
FriendsPantry

American · Desserts

Frozen custard (Milwaukee-style vanilla)

Contains egg (no meat or fish)

An extra-rich, dense vanilla ice cream made from an egg-yolk custard of cream, milk and sugar, churned with very little air and eaten soft, straight from the machine. Milwaukee, Wisconsin, calls itself the frozen custard capital of the world.

Frozen custard (Milwaukee-style vanilla) is an American dessert from United States, ready in about 4 hours 25 minutes and made with egg yolk, heavy cream and vanilla extract. It serves 6 and is rated intermediate to cook.

Start cooking
Frozen custard (Milwaukee-style vanilla)
Photo: Shake Shack Middle East, via TasteAtlas · licensed
Prep
15 min
Cook
10 min
Rest
4 h
Total
4 h 25 min
Serves
6
Level
Intermediate
Calories
465

Plus about 25 minutes churning in an ice-cream machine.

Main ingredients

Ingredients

6 servings

Method

  1. Step 1

    Heat the cream, milk (opens in a new tab) and salt in a saucepan (opens in a new tab) until steaming, with small bubbles at the edge.

  2. Step 2

    Whisk (opens in a new tab) the egg yolks (opens in a new tab) and sugar (opens in a new tab) until pale and thick. Pour in the hot cream in a thin stream, whisking all the time.

    Eggs being whisked in a bowl
    How it looks · Photo: Kampus Production on Pexels
  3. Step 3

    Return to the pan and cook over low heat, stirring constantly, until the custard thickens enough to coat a spoon and reaches 82 °C. Do not let it boil.

    Food safety: Cook the custard base to 82 °C (it should coat a spoon) so the egg yolks are safe, and chill it quickly before churning.

  4. Step 4

    Strain into a bowl set in iced water, stir in the vanilla (opens in a new tab) and cool, then chill for at least 4 hours or overnight.

    Liquid being strained through a sieve
    How it looks · Photo: Katerina Holmes on Pexels
  5. Step 5

    Churn in an ice-cream machine for about 20–25 minutes, until thick and soft-serve consistency. Serve straight away for the true frozen custard texture.

    • 25 min

    Stop as soon as it thickens; long churning beats in air, which is exactly what frozen custard avoids.

At a glance

Everything that goes into Frozen custard (Milwaukee-style vanilla), in a pan.
    • Egg yolk
    • Sugar
    • Heavy cream
    • Milk
    • Salt
    • Vanilla extract

About this dish

Origin
Coney Island, New York; famous in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, United States · Commonly attributedFrozen custard is credited to Coney Island around 1919 and spread to the Midwest via the 1933 Chicago World's Fair. In the US it must contain at least 1.4% egg yolk solids, and stands make it fresh through the day in continuous freezers.More food from United States
Map of the region around United States, with United States highlighted
United States
Dish
Dessert · Snack · Desserts · Ice cream & frozen desserts
Cooking method
Simmered, Whipped
Taste
creamy, sweet, rich
Diet
Vegetarian (lacto-ovo) · No gluten ingredients · No nut ingredients
All labelsVegetarian (lacto-ovo) · Eggetarian · Pescatarian · Flexitarian-friendly · No gluten ingredients · No nut ingredients · Pork-free · Beef-free · Low-sodium
Worked out from the ingredients. How labels work
Good for
Child-friendly · Make-ahead
Cook more with
Egg yolk · Heavy cream · Vanilla extract · Sugar · Milk

Allergens

  • Contains: Milkfrom heavy cream, milk
  • Contains: Eggsfrom egg yolk

Based on typical versions of these ingredients and not verified allergen-free. Brands differ and cross-contact happens, so always check labels. For severe allergies, follow your clinician’s advice.

Nutrition

465 kcal per serving

Calculated

1 serving ≈ 150 g · recipe makes 6

Where the energy comes from

  • Protein 5%
  • Carbohydrate 26%
  • Fat 69%
Nutrition per serving and per 100 g
NutrientPer servingPer 100 g
Energy465 kcal310 kcal
Protein6.4 g4.3 g
Carbohydrate30.2 g20.1 g
Net carbohydrate30.2 g20.1 g
Sugars29.8 g19.9 g
Added sugars25 g16.7 g
Fibre0 g0 g
Fat36 g24 g
Saturated fat21.6 g14.4 g
Trans fat——
Cholesterol283 mg189 mg
Sodium75 mg50 mg
Salt equivalent0.2 g0.1 g
Vitamins & minerals per serving
Potassium
157 mg
Calcium
126 mg
Iron
0.6 mg
Magnesium
11 mg
Vitamin A (RAE)
427 µg
Vitamin C
1 mg
Vitamin D
2.8 µg
Vitamin B12
0.7 µg
Folate (DFE)
30 µg

How these numbers were made

  • Calculated from USDA FoodData Central (SR Legacy) per-100 g values and the listed quantities.
  • “—” means the value isn’t known for enough of the ingredients; it is never zero by default.
  • Values are estimates for guidance, not for medical dosing. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service. FoodData Central, 2019. fdc.nal.usda.gov.

Good to know

Tips

  • Frozen custard is served warmer and softer than ice cream; eat it straight from the machine, or let frozen custard soften for 10 minutes before scooping.

Common mistakes

  • Overheating the custard, which scrambles the yolks.
  • Churning a warm base, which gives an icy texture.

Serve with

  • Serve in a cone or cup, as a 'concrete' blended with toppings, or in a sundae with hot fudge.

Food safety

  • Cook the custard base to 82 °C (it should coat a spoon) so the egg yolks are safe, and chill it quickly before churning.

Storage

  • Best the day it is made; keeps 1 week frozen in an airtight container, though it hardens.

Variations

  • Concrete: Frozen custard blended with mix-ins such as cookies, fruit or candy so thick it can be served upside down.
  • Flavour of the day: Milwaukee stands post a daily special flavour, such as butter pecan or chocolate peanut butter.

Original editorial recipe · FriendsPantry editorial · source: TasteAtlas (dish facts) · Not yet independently reviewed · Added

Recipe DNA

How this dish is built

Grouped by each ingredient’s role in the dish. Each band’s width is its share of the dish by weight. Choose a component to see what it does.

What the dish is built around

Main ingredient

Used in steps 1, 2

Reviews & corrections

Reviews come from signed-in cooks and appear after a moderator checks them. We never show made-up ratings.